 | Oscars entry: Barfi! draws copycat flak
29 September 2012
|
| 
India’s entry for best foreign language film at next year’s Oscars has become the latest Bollywood movie to draw flak for allegedly plagiarising foreign hits in a ‘mash-up’ of ripped-off scenes.
Barfi! has won over critics and cinema-goers for its portrayal of a love triangle between a deaf man named Barfi and two women, one of whom is autistic – not typical subject matter in the prolific Hindi-language film industry.
But since its release two weeks ago, several videos have spread through YouTube and social media sites highlighting a number of scenes that appear to draw heavily from international classics.
Film buffs spotted stark resemblances with clips from Gene Kelly’s hit Singin’ in the Rain (1952), Jackie Chan’s Project A (1983), Buster Keaton’s Cops (1922) and The Notebook (2004) starring Ryan Gosling among others.
The plot has been likened to Benny & Joon, the 1993 film starring Johnny Depp, while the soundtrack has drawn further comparisons with the musical score from Amelie, the 2001 hit starring Audrey Tautou.
One of the clearest sources of inspiration is Charlie Chaplin: one scene shows Barfi dodging a policeman through a sliding door, just as the king of silent film did in 1917?s The Adventurer.
Barfi! director Anurag Basu has hit back at critics, saying the film is intentionally paying homage to Chaplin in a similar way to The Artist, the black-and-white silent film that won Best Picture at this year’s Oscars.
“If I would have changed the shot, twisted things around and made it my own it would have been stealing,” Basu told the Indian TV show Headlines Today.
“I did shot-to-shot because they are famous iconic shots and scenes from famous masterpieces, every filmmaker knows them.”
Bollywood has come under fire before for remaking Hollywood flicks in the Hindi language, but Barfi! is under particular scrutiny because the movie-mad country is yet to win an Oscar in the foreign film category.
“So why would an Oscar jury pick a movie that reminds them of the very many movies they’ve seen before – and which include films that are now Hollywood legend?” asked online magazine Firstpost.
In one of several earlier Bollywood copycat rows, US studio 20th Century Fox submitted a $1.4-million claim in 2009 against BR Films over Banda Yeh Bindaas Hai, alleging it was an illegal remake of My Cousin Vinny. The case was settled out of court.
Image consultant Dilip Cherian worried that entering Barfi! into the Oscars could cause embarrassment for India in the long-run.
“The fact is that critics will start wondering at which stage does plagiarism end in Indian movies and at what stage is it inspiration,” he told Headlines Today.
Only three Indians films have been shortlisted in the foreign film category at the Oscars: Mother India in 1958, Salaam Bombay!(Hello Bombay!) in 1989, and Lagaan (Land Tax) in 2002.
Manju Borah, who chairs India’s selection committee, defended the latest choice.
“We selected Barfi! because of its treatment and freshness,” she told the Hindustan Times. “In any case, every filmmaker is inspired by some cinema.”
Film critic and curator Meenakshi Shedde said an “affectionate tribute” to world cinema, such as Barfi!, was not the same as stealing someone’s ideas – but she doubted for other reasons whether the film was the best selection.
“The criteria the Oscars look for is something uniquely Indian. Something that offers insights into the culture or society,” Shedde told AFP. | | See Also in Showbiz News
|
|  Shots fired at Cannes film festival, actors flee for cover
18 May 2013
CANNES: A man was arrested at the Cannes film festival on Friday after firing a starting pistol during a live TV broadcast on the palm-lined waterfront, sending actors Christoph Waltz and Daniel Auteuil running for cover.
French TV station Canal+ was interviewing Austria’s Oscar-winning Waltz and French actor Auteuil live on its nightly news show from a beach-front set before a crowd of spectators when a man fired two shots into the air.
“The bodyguards jumped over the barriers into the crowd ... Full Story |  Birth anniversary celebrations: ‘Manto was much more than a controversial writer’
18 May 2013
LAHORE : “In early ‘50s Manto predicted a close alliance between America and the Pakistani mullahs to defeat the Soviets,” said Shahid Nadeem, the writer of the play Kaun Hai Yeh Gustakh, staged by the Ajoka Theatre Group at the Alhamra Arts Council here on Friday.
He said the play shows Saadat Hassan Manto as a visionary. “I have always believed that Manto was much more than a controversial writer who wrote about sex and prostitutes,” he said.
The play was directed by Madeeha Gauhar and marks ... Full Story |  Shakira, Usher’s return to Voice?
18 May 2013
LOS?ANGELES: Shakira and Usher are set to return to ‘The Voice’ USA next year. The ‘Gypsy’ hitmaker - who recently announced she was leaving the talent show to focus on her family - and the ‘Scream’ singer are in negotiations with NBC to sign a deal for the sixth series in spring 2014. Original judges Christina Aguilera and Cee Lo Green have been confirmed to be taking their places on the panel for the next season later this year as part of alternating judges routine, with Adam Levine and Blake ... Full Story | Cannes hit by $1m jewel theft
18 May 2013
LOS ANGELES : Candice Glover, a soul singer from rural South Carolina, was named “American Idol”, becoming the first female singer to win the television singing competition since ... Full Story | Britney goes Ooh La La
18 May 2013
LOS ANGELES: Britney Spears has debuted her new song ‘Ooh La La’ online. The track will feature on the upcoming Smurfs 2 movie soundtrack.”I have always loved the Smurfs as a kid ... Full Story | Bieber’s monkey deadline
18 May 2013
MUNICH: Justin Bieber has just hours to reclaim his pet monkey from the animal shelter where it has been since it was seized by German customs, but he will have to pay thousands ... Full Story | Dylan joins US Arts Academy
18 May 2013
NEW YORK: US singer-songwriter Bob Dylan has been made an honorary member of the American Academy of Arts and Letters. Dylan, who was unable to attend the New York ceremony, said ... Full Story | Rihanna sues Topshop
18 May 2013
LONDON: Rihanna is suing Topshop for $5 million. The ‘Diamonds’ hitmaker is taking legal action against the UK high street fashion chain - which is owned by billionaire Sir Philip ... Full Story |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
| Susral Ke Rang Anokhay Director: Assorted
Writer: Assorted
Producer: Maria Wasti & Erum Bint e Shahid
Cast: Maria Wasti & Erum Bint e Shahid |
| | | Dil-E-Muztar Director: Shehzad Kashmiri
Writer: Aliya Bukhari
Producer: Momina Duraid
Cast: Sanam Jhung, Imran Imran Abbas, Sarwat Gilani, Humayun ... |
| | Athkeliyan Cast: Shehnaz Pervaiz, Mehmood Aslam, Azfar Rehman, Ayesha Toor, Fazila Lashari & Rehana Kaleem.
Producer: Barkat Saddiqi
Director: Kashif ... |
| | Yeh Zindagi Hai Cast: Javeria Saud, Imran Urooj, Sherry, Adeel Chaudhri, Nauman Habib, Anam, Salma Zafar, Saud, Ghazala Javed, Naeema Garaj
Written by: ... |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| | | | Dus Tak Kay Baad The panels of Experts that will be a regular part of the show are:
1. Nabeela (image consultant).
2. Munna Mushtaq (Fashion ... |
| | Sur Kshetra Host By: Ayesha Takia
Starring: Atif Aslam, Himesh Reshamiya, Abida Parveen, Runa Laila and Asha Bhosle. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
